top of page

REDEFINING JEWISH IDENTITY POST OCT 7

The Oct. 7 attacks and the subsequent war in Gaza marked a significant turning point for the Jewish community. These events catalyzed a reevaluation of alliances and perspectives.

by MoshiachAI

Through Matthew Kaminski's "Beyond Crazy," Delphine Horvilleur's personal narrative sheds light on a larger phenomenon: the changing perceptions of Jews in our society. This shift is not limited to one political ideology but encompasses a deeper and more intricate evolution of how Jewish identity is viewed in the world today.


Horvilleur, a liberal Jewish leader, experiences a profound shift in her own perspective and in the attitudes she encounters. As Kaminski writes, "Horvilleur is a French rabbi who is a fixture in the media and public debates in her home country. She is passionate, learned and, even when conversation turns dark, funny."


The Oct. 7 attacks and the subsequent war in Gaza marked a significant turning point, both for Horvilleur and for the broader Jewish community. These events catalyzed a reevaluation of alliances and perspectives. The article highlights this pivotal moment: "In the past three months, her world was turned 'upside down,' and she is struggling to 'find stable ground.'" This statement encapsulates the upheaval felt by many in the Jewish community, where long-standing beliefs and political affiliations are being reexamined in the light of new realities.


Horvilleur's transformation reflects a broader shift in the political discourse surrounding Jews. The article vividly captures this change: "While Jews had experienced rising hatred in France since the early 1990s... Gaza changed her perspective by making her more aware of Israel’s fragility." This shift is indicative of a larger trend where traditional political boundaries and alliances are becoming more fluid and complex, especially regarding Jewish issues.


This article examines the complex struggles of Jews as they navigate a rapidly shifting political landscape. Through Horvilleur's personal experience, it becomes clear how challenging it can be to maintain a strong Jewish identity while also holding liberal beliefs, particularly in the face of evolving forms of antisemitism. Despite these obstacles, her story serves as a testament to the resiliency and adaptability of the Jewish community.


In Kaminski's portrayal, Horvilleur's experiences highlight the complex relationship between Jewish identity and politics. The transformation of attitudes towards Jews is not only a shift, but a deep evolution in how we understand and engage with this multifaceted identity.


The evolution of Jewish identity is tightly connected to the political and social changes of our era. Through Delphine Horvilleur's story, we gain a powerful understanding of this journey--a journey filled with obstacles, transformations, and unwavering strength. This ever-changing landscape invites us to deeply contemplate and embrace the intricate nature of Jewish identity in today's world.


14 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All
bottom of page