top of page


Is it the comforting embrace of Menachem or the passionate, fervent love of Dovid? In the dichotomy of redemption, both facets echo our profound relationship with the Divine.

by ChatGPT

Rabbi Dovid Markel's teaching revolves around a profound observation found in the Yerushalmi. It presents two possible names for moshiach: Menachem and Dovid. He beautifully elucidates that these names are not arbitrary tags but are deeply descriptive of the nature of the coming Geulah itself. It could manifest as a soothing comfort for the millennia of Jewish pain, symbolized by the name Menachem. Alternatively, the Geulah might emerge as an overwhelming act of divine love, transcending past sufferings, epitomized by the name Dovid.

This leads us to a pivotal question: How do we, as a people who have witnessed both incredible suffering and immense divine love, reconcile these two possible realities of redemption? Which aspect of Geulah will take precedence? Is it the comforting embrace of Menachem or the passionate, fervent love of Dovid? It's this question that we will attempt to answer tonight as we embark on our exploration.

This teaching invites us into a profound understanding of the nature of redemption and the essential role of the Moshiach.

The Jewish people have faced considerable hardships throughout history, from the Egyptian exile to the Babylonian captivity, and from the Roman destruction to the lengthy and ongoing Diaspora. The sheer weight of our collective experience with suffering is immeasurable. It is within this context that the figure of Menachem emerges.


The Talmud in Sanhedrin 98b, the foundational text for discussions on Moshiach, mentions the name Menachem, drawing from the Hebrew word for "comfort." This name evokes the idea of consolation after a long period of hardship. The Moshiach as Menachem offers solace to a beleaguered nation, helping heal the wounds of centuries.

But why might this figure be associated with the month of Av? The month itself, "Menachem Av," is inherently tied to the theme of comfort. After commemorating the tragic events of the 9th of Av, we move towards the 15th of Av, a day associated with love and joy. This transition within the month mirrors the broader journey of the Jewish people: from the depths of despair to the heights of hope.


On the other hand, we have the name Dovid. King David, from whom this name is derived, was not just a historical figure but also a symbol of divine love and favor. The Tehillim (Psalms) 89:21 proclaims, "With My holy oil, I have anointed him." This legacy of David centers around the beloved relationship between the Divine and His people.

Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, in his work Likkutei Torah, frequently reflects upon the unique relationship between God and Israel. The month of Elul becomes a backdrop for this divine romance, with the acronym "אני לדודי ודודי לי" (Ani L'Dodi v'Dodi Li - "I am my beloved's, and my beloved is mine") echoing throughout. This sense of closeness, of God's overwhelming love that transcends our reality, is epitomized in the figure of Dovid.


While the two figures might seem separate, they are deeply intertwined. Chassidic teachings, particularly from the Lubavitcher Rebbe, emphasize the different ways in which Moshiach can arrive. Whether as a natural progression from our history, embodied by Menachem, or as a sudden, overwhelming act of divine love, seen in Dovid.

As we await the final redemption, these names serve not just as identifiers for Moshiach but as markers for our collective spiritual journey. Each name, Menachem and Dovid, represents a facet of our deep and multifaceted relationship with the Divine.

In essence, the redemption we yearn for is not just a physical or geopolitical one but a profound shift in our spiritual and emotional landscapes. Whether through the comforting embrace of Menachem or the passionate love of Dovid, the ultimate Geulah will bring both solace from our past and an overwhelming love for our future.

May we merit to see the coming of Moshiach, in whichever form he takes, speedily in our days.

18 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page